Skip to content

Tailoring 3D Printed Concrete Through Explainable Artificial Intelligence (2023-07)

10.1016/j.istruc.2023.07.040

Ghasemi Alireza,  Naser Mohannad
Journal Article - Structures, Vol. 56, No. 104850

Abstract

Advances on the construction front continue to rise as the next industrial revolution (Construction 4.0) nears. One promising front revolves around additively fabricated or simply 3D printed concrete. The growing number of ongoing parallel research programs has now made it possible to collect a large amount of data on such concrete as, up to this point, the open literature lacks a comprehensive database. Thus, this paper presents the largest database spanning over 300 experiments on 3D printed concrete. This database is then examined via multilinear regression as well as two explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) algorithms, namely, Random Forest and XGBoost, to arrive at a working model capable of predicting the compressive strength property for 3D concrete mixtures that incorporate the following seven features: age of specimens, as well as the magnitude of cement, water, fly ash, silica fume, fine aggregate, and superplasticizer. Findings from this work infer the superiority of XAI models in predicting the strength property of 3D printed concrete. Our analysis identifies two features, namely, the age of specimens and the quantity of fine aggregate, as the most important features that can accurately predict the compressive strength property. Finally, the deployed explainability methods successfully quantified the highly nonlinear relations between the selected features and compressive strength, and this newly acquired knowledge can help tailor functional concrete mixtures.

71 References

  1. Al-Qutaifi Sarah, Nazari Ali, Bagheri Ali (2018-07)
    Mechanical Properties of Layered Geopolymer Structures Applicable in Concrete 3D Printing
  2. Álvarez-Fernández Martina, Prendes-Gero María, González-Nicieza Celestino, Guerrero-Miguel Diego-José et al. (2021-02)
    Optimum Mix-Design for 3D Concrete Printing Using Mining-Tailings:
    A Case Study in Spain
  3. Assaad Joseph, Hamzeh Farook, Hamad Bilal (2020-05)
    Qualitative Assessment of Interfacial Bonding in 3D Printing Concrete Exposed to Frost-Attack
  4. Baz Bilal, Aouad Georges, Khalil Noura, Rémond Sébastien (2020-11)
    Inter-Layer Reinforcement of 3D Printed Concrete Elements
  5. Baz Bilal, Aouad Georges, Rémond Sébastien (2020-01)
    Effect of the Printing Method and Mortar’s Workability on Pull-Out Strength of 3D Printed Elements
  6. Bos Freek, Bosco Emanuela, Salet Theo (2018-11)
    Ductility of 3D Printed Concrete Reinforced with Short Straight Steel-Fibers
  7. Bos Freek, Wolfs Robert, Ahmed Zeeshan, Salet Theo (2016-08)
    Additive Manufacturing of Concrete in Construction:
    Potentials and Challenges of 3D Concrete Printing
  8. Chen Yu, Li Zhenming, Figueiredo Stefan, Çopuroğlu Oğuzhan et al. (2019-04)
    Limestone and Calcined-Clay-Based Sustainable Cementitious Materials for 3D Concrete Printing:
    A Fundamental Study of Extrudability and Early-Age Strength Development
  9. Cho Seung, Kruger Jacques, Rooyen Algurnon, Zeranka Stephan et al. (2019-09)
    Rheology of 3D Printable Lightweight Foam-Concrete Incorporating Nano-Silica
  10. Chu Shaohua, Li Leo, Kwan Albert (2020-09)
    Development of Extrudable High-Strength Fiber-Reinforced Concrete Incorporating Nano-Calcium-Carbonate
  11. Cui Hongzhi, Yu Shiheng, Cao Xiangpeng, Yang Haibin (2022-03)
    Evaluation of Printability and Thermal Properties of 3D Printed Concrete Mixed with Phase-Change-Materials
  12. Ding Tao, Qin Fei, Xiao Jianzhuang, Chen Xiaoming et al. (2022-01)
    Experimental Study on the Bond Behavior Between Steel-Bars and 3D Printed Concrete
  13. Ding Tao, Xiao Jianzhuang, Qin Fei, Duan Zhenhua (2020-03)
    Mechanical Behavior of 3D Printed Mortar with Recycled Sand at Early-Ages
  14. Ding Tao, Xiao Jianzhuang, Zou Shuai, Wang Yu (2020-06)
    Hardened Properties of Layered 3D Printed Concrete with Recycled Sand
  15. Diniz Hugo, Martinelli Antônio, Cabral Kleber, Ferreira Ruan et al. (2023-01)
    Synergistic Effects of the Use of Metakaolin, Sand and Water on the Properties of Cementitious Composites for 3D Printing
  16. Federowicz Karol, Kaszyńska Maria, Zieliński Adam, Hoffmann Marcin (2020-06)
    Effect of Curing Methods on Shrinkage Development in 3D Printed Concrete
  17. Gebhard Lukas, Mata-Falcón Jaime, Anton Ana-Maria, Dillenburger Benjamin et al. (2021-04)
    Structural Behavior of 3D Printed Concrete Beams with Various Reinforcement-Strategies
  18. Hack Norman, Mai (née Dressler) Inka, Brohmann Leon, Gantner Stefan et al. (2020-03)
    Injection 3D Concrete Printing (I3DCP):
    Basic Principles and Case Studies
  19. Hambach Manuel, Rutzen Matthias, Volkmer Dirk (2019-02)
    Properties of 3D-Printed Fiber-Reinforced Portland Cement-Paste
  20. Hambach Manuel, Volkmer Dirk (2017-02)
    Properties of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Portland-Cement-Paste
  21. Heever Marchant, Bester Frederick, Kruger Jacques, Zijl Gideon (2021-07)
    Mechanical Characterisation for Numerical Simulation of Extrusion-Based 3D Concrete Printing
  22. Hou Shaodan, Duan Zhenhua, Xiao Jianzhuang, Ye Jun (2020-12)
    A Review of 3D Printed Concrete:
    Performance-Requirements, Testing Measurements and Mix-Design
  23. Jo Jun, Jo Byung, Cho Woohyun, Kim Jung-Hoon (2020-03)
    Development of a 3D Printer for Concrete Structures:
    Laboratory Testing of Cementitious Materials
  24. Joh Changbin, Lee Jungwoo, Bui The, Park Jihun et al. (2020-11)
    Buildability and Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Concrete
  25. Kaszyńska Maria, Skibicki Szymon, Hoffmann Marcin (2020-12)
    3D Concrete Printing for Sustainable Construction
  26. Kazemian Ali, Yuan Xiao, Cochran Evan, Khoshnevis Behrokh (2017-04)
    Cementitious Materials for Construction-Scale 3D Printing:
    Laboratory Testing of Fresh Printing Mixture
  27. Khalil Noura, Aouad Georges, Cheikh Khadija, Rémond Sébastien (2017-09)
    Use of Calcium-Sulfoaluminate-Cements for Setting-Control of 3D Printing Mortars
  28. Khoshnevis Behrokh (2003-11)
    Automated Construction by Contour Crafting:
    Related Robotics and Information Technologies
  29. Kloft Harald, Krauss Hans-Werner, Hack Norman, Herrmann Eric et al. (2020-05)
    Influence of Process Parameters on the Inter-Layer Bond Strength of Concrete Elements Additive Manufactured by Shotcrete 3D Printing
  30. Kruger Jacques, Zeranka Stephan, Zijl Gideon (2019-07)
    An Ab-Inito Approach for Thixotropy Characterisation of Nano-Particle-Infused 3D Printable Concrete
  31. Le Thanh, Austin Simon, Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard et al. (2012-01)
    Mix-Design and Fresh Properties for High-Performance Printing Concrete
  32. Li Zhijian, Wang Li, Ma Guowei, Sanjayan Jay et al. (2020-07)
    Strength and Ductility Enhancement of 3D Printing Structure Reinforced by Embedding Continuous Micro-Cables
  33. Li Leo, Xiao Bofeng, Fang Z., Xiong Z. et al. (2020-11)
    Feasibility of Glass-Basalt Fiber-Reinforced Seawater Coral Sand Mortar for 3D Printing
  34. Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard, Le Thanh, Austin Simon et al. (2011-07)
    Developments in Construction-Scale Additive Manufacturing Processes
  35. Liu Chao, Zhang Rongfei, Liu Huawei, He Chunhui et al. (2021-11)
    Analysis of the Mechanical Performance and Damage Mechanism for 3D Printed Concrete Based on Pore-Structure
  36. Long Wujian, Tao Jie-Lin, Lin Can, Gu Yucun et al. (2019-08)
    Rheology and Buildability of Sustainable Cement-Based Composites Containing Micro-Crystalline Cellulose for 3D Printing
  37. Ma Guowei, Li Zhijian, Wang Li (2017-12)
    Printable Properties of Cementitious Material Containing Copper-Tailings for Extrusion-Based 3D Printing
  38. Ma Lei, Zhang Qing, Jia Zijian, Liu Chao et al. (2021-11)
    Effect of Drying Environment on Mechanical Properties, Internal RH and Pore-Structure of 3D Printed Concrete
  39. Mai (née Dressler) Inka, Freund Niklas, Lowke Dirk (2020-01)
    The Effect of Accelerator Dosage on Fresh Concrete Properties and on Inter-Layer Strength in Shotcrete 3D Printing
  40. Mechtcherine Viktor, Nerella Venkatesh, Will Frank, Näther Mathias et al. (2019-08)
    Large-Scale Digital Concrete Construction:
    CONPrint3D Concept for On-Site, Monolithic 3D Printing
  41. Meurer Maximilian, Claßen Martin (2021-02)
    Mechanical Properties of Hardened 3D Printed Concretes and Mortars:
    Development of a Consistent Experimental Characterization-Strategy
  42. Nerella Venkatesh, Hempel Simone, Mechtcherine Viktor (2019-02)
    Effects of Layer-Interface Properties on Mechanical Performance of Concrete Elements Produced by Extrusion-Based 3D Printing
  43. Nerella Venkatesh, Mechtcherine Viktor (2019-02)
    Studying the Printability of Fresh Concrete for Formwork-Free Concrete Onsite 3D Printing Technology (CONPrint3D)
  44. Overmeir Anne, Figueiredo Stefan, Šavija Branko, Bos Freek et al. (2022-02)
    Design and Analyses of Printable Strain-Hardening Cementitious Composites with Optimized Particle-Size-Distribution
  45. Panda Biranchi, Paul Suvash, Mohamed Nisar, Tay Yi et al. (2017-09)
    Measurement of Tensile Bond Strength of 3D Printed Geopolymer Mortar
  46. Panda Biranchi, Paul Suvash, Tan Ming (2017-07)
    Anisotropic Mechanical Performance of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Sustainable Construction-Material
  47. Panda Biranchi, Ruan Shaoqin, Unluer Cise, Tan Ming (2018-11)
    Improving the 3D Printability of High-Volume Fly-Ash Mixtures via the Use of Nano-Attapulgite-Clay
  48. Papachristoforou Michail, Mitsopoulos Vasilios, Stefanidou Maria (2018-10)
    Evaluation of Workability Parameters in 3D Printing Concrete
  49. Perrot Arnaud, Rangeard Damien, Pierre Alexandre (2015-02)
    Structural Build-Up of Cement-Based Materials Used for 3D Printing-Extrusion-Techniques
  50. Pham Luong, Lu Guoxing, Tran Jonathan (2022-02)
    Influences of Printing-Pattern on Mechanical Performance of Three-Dimensional-Printed Fiber-Reinforced Concrete
  51. Putten Jolien, Snoeck Didier, Coensel R., Schutter Geert et al. (2020-12)
    Early-Age Shrinkage Phenomena of 3D Printed Cementitious Materials with Superabsorbent Polymers
  52. Rahul Attupurathu, Mohan Manu, Schutter Geert, Tittelboom Kim (2021-10)
    3D Printable Concrete with Natural and Recycled Coarse Aggregates:
    Rheological, Mechanical and Shrinkage Behavior
  53. Rahul Attupurathu, Santhanam Manu (2020-02)
    Evaluating the Printability of Concretes Containing Lightweight Coarse Aggregates
  54. Rahul Attupurathu, Santhanam Manu, Meena Hitesh, Ghani Zimam (2018-12)
    3D Printable Concrete:
    Mixture-Design and Test-Methods
  55. Rahul Attupurathu, Santhanam Manu, Meena Hitesh, Ghani Zimam (2019-08)
    Mechanical Characterization of 3D Printable Concrete
  56. Roussel Nicolas (2018-05)
    Rheological Requirements for Printable Concretes
  57. Rushing Todd, Chaar Ghassan, Eick Brian, Burroughs Jedadiah et al. (2017-01)
    Investigation of Concrete Mixtures for Additive Construction
  58. Shakor Pshtiwan, Nejadi Shami, Paul Gavin (2019-05)
    A Study into the Effect of Different Nozzles Shapes and Fiber-Reinforcement in 3D Printed Mortar
  59. Shakor Pshtiwan, Nejadi Shami, Sutjipto Sheila, Paul Gavin et al. (2020-01)
    Effects of Deposition-Velocity in the Presence-Absence of E6-Glass-Fiber on Extrusion-Based 3D Printed Mortar
  60. Singh Amardeep, Liu Qiong, Xiao Jianzhuang, Lyu Qifeng (2022-02)
    Mechanical and Macrostructural Properties of 3D Printed Concrete Dosed with Steel-Fibers under Different Loading-Direction
  61. Tao Yaxin, Rahul Attupurathu, Lesage Karel, Tittelboom Kim et al. (2021-11)
    Mechanical and Microstructural Properties of 3D Printable Concrete in the Context of the Twin-Pipe Pumping-Strategy
  62. Tay Yi, Qian Ye, Tan Ming (2019-05)
    Printability-Region for 3D Concrete Printing Using Slump- and Slump-Flow-Test
  63. Weng Yiwei, Li Mingyang, Tan Ming, Qian Shunzhi (2018-01)
    Design 3D Printing Cementitious Materials via Fuller-Thompson-Theory and Marson-Percy-Model
  64. Weng Yiwei, Lu Bing, Li Mingyang, Liu Zhixin et al. (2018-09)
    Empirical Models to Predict Rheological Properties of Fiber-Reinforced Cementitious Composites for 3D Printing
  65. Xiao Jianzhuang, Chen Zixuan, Ding Tao, Zou Shuai (2021-10)
    Bending Behavior of Steel-Cable-Reinforced 3D Printed Concrete in the Direction Perpendicular to the Interfaces
  66. Xiao Jianzhuang, Lv Zhenyuan, Duan Zhenhua, Hou Shaodan (2022-03)
    Study on Preparation and Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Concrete with Different Aggregate-Combinations
  67. Ye Junhong, Cui Can, Yu Jiangtao, Yu Kequan et al. (2021-02)
    Effect of Polyethylene-Fiber Content on Workability and Mechanical-Anisotropic Properties of 3D Printed Ultra-High-Ductile Concrete
  68. Yu Kequan, McGee Wesley, Ng Tsz, Zhu He et al. (2021-02)
    3D Printable Engineered Cementitious Composites:
    Fresh and Hardened Properties
  69. Yu Shiwei, Sanjayan Jay, Du Hongjian (2022-07)
    Effects of Cement Mortar Characteristics on Aggregate-Bed 3D Concrete Printing
  70. Zhang Jingchuan, Wang Jialiang, Dong Sufen, Yu Xun et al. (2019-07)
    A Review of the Current Progress and Application of 3D Printed Concrete
  71. Zhu Binrong, Nematollahi Behzad, Pan Jinlong, Zhang Yang et al. (2021-04)
    3D Concrete Printing of Permanent Formwork for Concrete Column Construction

20 Citations

  1. Iqbal Imtiaz, Kasim Tala, Besklubova Svetlana, Mustafa Ali et al. (2025-12)
    Passive Determination of Anisotropic Compressive Strength of 3D Printed Concrete Using Multiple Neural Networks Enhanced with Explainable Machine Learning (XML)
  2. Abbas Yassir, Alsaif Abdulaziz (2025-11)
    Explainable Data-Driven Modeling for Optimized Mix Design of 3D-Printed Concrete:
    Interpreting Nonlinear Synergies Among Binder Components and Proportions
  3. Chen Baixi, Yang Lei, Jiang Sheng (2025-09)
    Stochastic Analysis of 3D Concrete Printing Process with Curvature and Inclination by Explainable Data-Driven Modelling
  4. Khodadadi Nima, Roghani Hossein, Caso Francisco, Kenawy El‐Sayed et al. (2025-06)
    Machine Learning Approach for the Flexural Strength of 3D‐Printed Fiber‐reinforced Concrete Based on the Meta‐heuristic Algorithm
  5. Garcés Gonzalo, García-Alvarado Rodrigo, Bunster Victor, Muñoz-Sanguinetti Claudia (2025-06)
    Additive Construction 4.0:
    A Systematic Review of 3D Concrete Printing for Construction 4.0
  6. Mohamed Osama, Mishra Anamika, Isam Fida (2025-05)
    An Overview of 3D Printed Concrete for Building Structures:
    Material Properties, Sustainability, Future Opportunities, and Challenges
  7. Asif Usama (2025-05)
    Comparative Analysis of Evolutionary Computational Methods for Predicting Mechanical Properties of Fiber-Reinforced 3D Printed Concrete
  8. Gardan Julien, Hedjazi Lofti, Attajer Ali (2025-02)
    Additive Manufacturing in Construction:
    State of the Art and Emerging Trends in Civil Engineering
  9. Vasilić Ksenija (2025-02)
    Standardization Aspects of Concrete 3D Printing
  10. Zhang Yonghong, Cui Suping, Yang Bohao, Wang Xinxin et al. (2025-01)
    Research on 3D Printing Concrete Mechanical Properties-Prediction-Model Based on Machine-Learning
  11. Lori Ali, Mehrali Mehdi (2025-01)
    Filament-Geometry-Control of Printable Geopolymer Using Experimental and Data-Driven Approaches
  12. Khan Mirza, Ahmed Aayzaz, Ali Tariq, Qureshi Muhammad et al. (2024-12)
    Comprehensive Review of 3D Printed Concrete, Life Cycle Assessment, AI and ML Models:
    Materials, Engineered Properties and Techniques for Additive Manufacturing
  13. Arif Muhammad, Jan Faizullah, Rezzoug Aïssa, Afridi Muhammad et al. (2024-11)
    Data-Driven Models for Predicting Compressive Strength of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Concrete Using Interpretable Machine Learning Algorithms
  14. Ma Xin-Rui, Wang Xian-Lin, Chen Shi-Zi (2024-09)
    Trustworthy Machine Learning-Enhanced 3D Concrete Printing:
    Predicting Bond Strength and Designing Reinforcement Embedment Length
  15. Wang Jun, Liu Zhenhua, Hou Jia, Ge Mengmeng (2024-04)
    Research-Progress and Trend-Analysis of Concrete 3D Printing Technology Based on CiteSpace
  16. Şahin Hatice, Mardani Ali, Beytekin Hatice (2024-02)
    Effect of Silica-Fume Utilization on Structural Build-Up, Mechanical and Dimensional Stability Performance of Fiber-Reinforced 3D Printable Concrete
  17. Zhu Ronghua, Egbe King-James, Salehi Hadi, Shi Zhongtian et al. (2024-01)
    Eco-Friendly 3D Printed Concrete with Fine Aggregate Replacements:
    Fabrication, Characterization and Machine Learning Prediction
  18. Alyami Mana, Khan Majid, Javed Muhammad, Ali Mujahid et al. (2023-12)
    Application of Metaheuristic Optimization Algorithms in Predicting the Compressive Strength of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Concrete
  19. Alyami Mana, Khan Majid, Fawad Muhammad, Nawahz R. et al. (2023-11)
    Predictive Modeling for Compressive Strength of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Concrete Using Machine Learning Algorithms
  20. Mollah Md., Comminal Raphaël, Silva Wilson, Šeta Berin et al. (2023-07)
    Computational Fluid Dynamics Modelling and Experimental Analysis of Reinforcement-Bar-Integration in 3D Concrete Printing

BibTeX
@article{ghas_nase.2023.T3PCTEAI,
  author            = "Alireza Ghasemi and Mohannad Z. Naser",
  title             = "Tailoring 3D Printed Concrete Through Explainable Artificial Intelligence",
  doi               = "10.1016/j.istruc.2023.07.040",
  year              = "2023",
  journal           = "Structures",
  volume            = "56",
  pages             = "104850",
}
Formatted Citation

A. Ghasemi and M. Z. Naser, “Tailoring 3D Printed Concrete Through Explainable Artificial Intelligence”, Structures, vol. 56, p. 104850, 2023, doi: 10.1016/j.istruc.2023.07.040.

Ghasemi, Alireza, and Mohannad Z. Naser. “Tailoring 3D Printed Concrete Through Explainable Artificial Intelligence”. Structures 56 (2023): 104850. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.istruc.2023.07.040.