Skip to content

Improving Surface-Finish-Quality in Extrusion-Based 3D Concrete Printing Using Machine-Learning-Based Extrudate-Geometry-Control (2020-02)

10.1080/17452759.2020.1713580

Lao Wenxin,  Li Mingyang,  Wong Teck,  Tan Ming,  Tjahjowidodo Tegoeh
Journal Article - Virtual and Physical Prototyping, Vol. 15, Iss. 2, pp. 178-193

Abstract

3D Concrete Printing (3DCP) has been gaining popularity in the past few years. Due to the nature of line-by-line printing and the slump of the material deposition in each extruded line, 3D printed structures exhibit obvious lines or marks at the layer interface, which affects surface finish quality and potentially affect bonding strength between layers. This makes it necessary to control the extrudate formation in 3DCP. However, it is difficult to directly analyse the extrudate formation process because the extrudate shape depends on many parameters. In this paper, a machine learning technique is applied to correlate the formation of the extrudate to the printing parameters using an Artificial Neural Network model. The training data for the model development was obtained from extrudates printed in 3DCP experiments. The performance of the trained model was experimentally validated and the predicted extrudate geometry resulting from the developed model showed good agreement to the actual extrudate geometry. Subsequently, the developed model was used to find proper nozzle shapes to produce designated extrudate geometries. Significant improvement on the printing quality was demonstrated using nozzle shapes generated from the model on 3D printed objects consisting a vertical wall, an inclined wall and a curved part.

25 References

  1. Borg Costanzi Christopher, Ahmed Zeeshan, Schipper Roel, Bos Freek et al. (2018-07)
    3D Printing Concrete on Temporary Surfaces:
    The Design and Fabrication of a Concrete Shell Structure
  2. Bos Freek, Bosco Emanuela, Salet Theo (2018-11)
    Ductility of 3D Printed Concrete Reinforced with Short Straight Steel-Fibers
  3. Bos Freek, Wolfs Robert, Ahmed Zeeshan, Salet Theo (2016-08)
    Additive Manufacturing of Concrete in Construction:
    Potentials and Challenges of 3D Concrete Printing
  4. Buswell Richard, Silva Wilson, Jones Scott, Dirrenberger Justin (2018-06)
    3D Printing Using Concrete-Extrusion:
    A Roadmap for Research
  5. Buswell Richard, Soar Rupert, Gibb Alistar, Thorpe Tony (2006-06)
    Freeform Construction:
    Mega-Scale Rapid Manufacturing for Construction
  6. Cesaretti Giovanni, Dini Enrico, Kestelier Xavier, Colla Valentina et al. (2013-08)
    Building Components for an Outpost on the Lunar Soil by Means of a Novel 3D Printing Technology
  7. Gosselin Clément, Duballet Romain, Roux Philippe, Gaudillière-Jami Nadja et al. (2016-03)
    Large-Scale 3D Printing of Ultra-High-Performance Concrete:
    A New Processing Route for Architects and Builders
  8. Khoshnevis Behrokh (2003-11)
    Automated Construction by Contour Crafting:
    Related Robotics and Information Technologies
  9. Khoshnevis Behrokh, Bekey George (2002-09)
    Automated Construction Using Contour Crafting:
    Applications on Earth and Beyond
  10. Khoshnevis Behrokh, Dutton Rosanne (1998-01)
    Innovative Rapid Prototyping Process Makes Large-Sized, Smooth-Surfaced Complex Shapes in a Wide Variety of Materials
  11. Khoshnevis Behrokh, Hwang Dooil, Yao Ke, Yeh Zhenghao (2006-05)
    Mega-Scale Fabrication by Contour Crafting
  12. Khoshnevis Behrokh, Thangavelu Madhu, Yuan Xiao, Zhang Jing (2013-09)
    Advances in Contour Crafting Technology for Extraterrestrial Settlement Infrastructure Buildup
  13. Kreiger Eric, Kreiger Megan, Case Michael (2019-04)
    Development of the Construction Processes for Reinforced Additively Constructed Concrete
  14. Lao Wenxin, Li Mingyang, Masia Lorenzo, Tan Ming (2017-08)
    Approaching Rectangular Extrudate in 3D Printing for Building and Construction by Experimental Iteration of Nozzle Design
  15. Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard, Le Thanh, Austin Simon et al. (2011-07)
    Developments in Construction-Scale Additive Manufacturing Processes
  16. Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard, Valentine Philip, Piker Daniel et al. (2016-06)
    Modelling Curved-Layered Printing Paths for Fabricating Large-Scale Construction Components
  17. Liu Zhixin, Li Mingyang, Weng Yiwei, Wong Teck et al. (2018-12)
    Mixture-Design-Approach to Optimize the Rheological Properties of the Material Used in 3D Cementitious Material-Printing
  18. Roussel Nicolas (2018-05)
    Rheological Requirements for Printable Concretes
  19. Tan Kang (2018-09)
    The Framework of Combining Artificial Intelligence and Construction 3D Printing in Civil Engineering
  20. Tay Yi, Li Mingyang, Tan Ming (2019-04)
    Effect of Printing Parameters in 3D Concrete Printing:
    Printing Region and Support Structures
  21. Tay Yi, Panda Biranchi, Paul Suvash, Mohamed Nisar et al. (2017-05)
    3D Printing Trends in Building and Construction Industry:
    A Review
  22. Weng Yiwei, Li Mingyang, Tan Ming, Qian Shunzhi (2018-01)
    Design 3D Printing Cementitious Materials via Fuller-Thompson-Theory and Marson-Percy-Model
  23. Wolfs Robert, Bos Freek, Strien Emiel, Salet Theo (2017-06)
    A Real-Time Height Measurement and Feedback System for 3D Concrete Printing
  24. Zareiyan Babak, Khoshnevis Behrokh (2018-05)
    Effects of Mixture Ingredients on Extrudability of Concrete in Contour Crafting
  25. Zhang Xu, Li Mingyang, Lim Jian, Weng Yiwei et al. (2018-08)
    Large-Scale 3D Printing by a Team of Mobile Robots

61 Citations

  1. Ding Yao, Liu Yifan, Yang Bo, Liu Jiepeng et al. (2026-01)
    Application of Artificial Intelligence Technology in 3D Concrete Printing Quality Inspection and Control:
    A State-of-the-Art Review
  2. Iqbal Imtiaz, Kasim Tala, Besklubova Svetlana, Mustafa Ali et al. (2025-12)
    Passive Determination of Anisotropic Compressive Strength of 3D Printed Concrete Using Multiple Neural Networks Enhanced with Explainable Machine Learning (XML)
  3. Baah Thomas, Kim Heejeong, Latypov Marat (2025-11)
    Multi-Objective Adaptive Experimental Approach for Optimizing 3D Concrete Printing Mixtures and Parameters Incorporating Construction and Demolition Waste for Sustainable Construction
  4. Faleschini Flora, Trento Daniel, Zanini Mariano (2025-11)
    Earth as a Building Material:
    From Traditional Building Techniques to Additive Manufacturing
  5. Foulki Rida, Mesoudy Mouad, Cherkaoui Khalid (2025-10)
    Numerical and Theoretical Analysis of Pumping and Extrusion in 3D Concrete Printing
  6. Verma Shilpi, Parghi Anant (2025-10)
    Machine Learning-Based Prediction of Compressive Strength in Additive Manufacturing of Concrete Technology
  7. Uddin Md, Mostazid Md, Faysal Md, Shi Xinjun (2025-10)
    Developing a Novel Strength Predictive Modeling for 3D Printable Geopolymer Concrete:
    An Interpretable Data-Driven Approach
  8. Paritala Spandana, Raj Shubham, Singh Prashant, Subramaniam Kolluru (2025-09)
    Designing 3D Printable Concrete by Integrating the Influence of Aggregate Characteristics
  9. Mawas Karam, Maboudi Mehdi, Gerke Markus (2025-09)
    A Review on Geometry and Surface Inspection in 3D Concrete Printing
  10. Murtaza Ghulam, Baldinelli Giorgio (2025-08)
    Revolutionizing Architecture:
    3D Printing in Large Construction Industry and Strategic Innovations for Enhanced Performance
  11. Kiyani Muhammad, Hussain Syed, Emaan Rajja, Kamal Muhammad et al. (2025-08)
    Influence of Process Parameters on 3D Concrete Printing:
    A Step Towards Standardized Approaches
  12. Disu Oluwatimilehin, Ismail Sikiru, Wood Luke, Chrysanthou Andreas et al. (2025-08)
    Experimental Study on Buildability of 3D-Printed Cement-Based Structures Using Aluminium Sulphate
  13. Li Qiyan, Su Anshuang, Gao Xiaojian (2025-06)
    Improvement of Interlayer Performance of 3D Printable Magnesium Oxysulfate Cement-Based Materials by Carbonation Curing
  14. Jalil Siti Nur Natasha Abdul, Rizal Alias Ahmad, Alias Aizat (2025-06)
    Challenges and Strategies in Implementing 3D Concrete Printing (3DCP) Technology in Malaysia:
    Materials and Design Codes
  15. Tang Boyang, Yan Jiachuan, Han Xiaoyu, Lin Yini et al. (2025-05)
    Mechanical Properties of Extrusion-Based 3D-Printed Concrete Considering the Thickness of the Printed Layer and Printing Time Interval
  16. Zhang Ziqi, Pan Tinghong, Guoa Rongxin, Lin Runsheng et al. (2025-04)
    Simulation and Analysis of Material Stacking and Migration Induced by Extrusion Behavior in 3D Printed Concrete
  17. Liu Zhenbang, Li Mingyang, Wang Xiangyu, Wong Teck et al. (2025-03)
    Investigate Mechanisms of Different Printing Parameters on the Mechanical Anisotropy of 3D Concrete Printing Elements by Using Computed Tomography Scan and Computational Fluid Dynamics Methods
  18. Özalp Abdulkadir, Aldemir Alper (2025-03)
    Artificial Intelligence-Based Displacement Capacity Prediction Tool for Three-Dimensional Printed Concrete Walls
  19. Gardan Julien, Hedjazi Lofti, Attajer Ali (2025-02)
    Additive Manufacturing in Construction:
    State of the Art and Emerging Trends in Civil Engineering
  20. Cui Weijiu, Liu Wenliang, Guo Ruyi, Da Wan et al. (2025-02)
    Geometrical Quality Inspection in 3D Concrete Printing Using AI-Assisted Computer Vision
  21. Zhang Yonghong, Cui Suping, Yang Bohao, Wang Xinxin et al. (2025-01)
    Research on 3D Printing Concrete Mechanical Properties-Prediction-Model Based on Machine-Learning
  22. Schossler Rodrigo, Ullah Shafi, Alajlan Zaid, Yu Xiong (2025-01)
    Data-Driven Analysis in 3D Concrete Printing:
    Predicting and Optimizing Construction Mixtures
  23. Mousavi Moein, Bengar Habib, Mousavi Fateme, Mahdavinia Pooneh et al. (2024-12)
    Inter-Layer Bond Strength Prediction of 3D Printable Concrete Using Artificial Neural Network:
    Experimental and Modeling Study
  24. Wang Li, Lin Wenyu, Wan Qian, Li Zhijian et al. (2024-11)
    Manufacturing Accuracy Improvement of Concrete Product by Hybrid Additive-Subtractive Method Based on the Time-Dependent Characteristics of Cementitious Materials
  25. Ma Xin-Rui, Wang Xian-Lin, Chen Shi-Zi (2024-09)
    Trustworthy Machine Learning-Enhanced 3D Concrete Printing:
    Predicting Bond Strength and Designing Reinforcement Embedment Length
  26. Paritala Spandana, Singh Prashant, Kamakshi Tippabhotla, Subramaniam Kolluru (2024-09)
    Assessment of Printability of Concrete Based on Packing of Aggregates
  27. Farrokhsiar Paniz, Gürsoy Benay, Duarte José (2024-08)
    A Comprehensive Review on Integrating Vision-Based Sensing in Extrusion-Based 3D Printing Processes:
    Toward Geometric Monitoring of Extrusion-Based 3D Concrete Printing
  28. Zhang Nan, Sanjayan Jay (2024-07)
    Pumping-Less 3D Concrete Printing Using Quick Nozzle Mixing
  29. Birru Bizu, Rehman Atta, Kim Jung-Hoon (2024-06)
    Comparative Analysis of Structural Build-Up in One-Component Stiff and Two-Component Shotcrete-Accelerated Set-on-Demand Mixtures for 3D Concrete Printing
  30. Otto Jens, Maiwald Patrick (2024-05)
    Classification and Automated Quality Assurance of 3D Concrete Printed Surfaces
  31. Zuo Zibo, Corte Wouter, Huang Yulin, Chen Xiaoming et al. (2024-05)
    Strategies Towards Large-Scale 3D Printing Without Size-Constraints
  32. Lu Bing, Wang Lining, Wang Xiangyu, Tan Ming et al. (2024-04)
    Development of Robotic Sprayable Self-Sensing Cementitious Material for Smart Structural Health Monitoring
  33. Wang Yibo, Ren Changzai, Yan Ming, Ao Chenyang (2024-04)
    Blockage-Mechanism-Analysis and Optimization Design of 3D Concrete Print-Head
  34. Živković Milijana, Žujović Maša, Milošević Jelena (2023-09)
    Architectural 3D Printed Structures Created Using Artificial Intelligence:
    A Review of Techniques and Applications
  35. Paritala Spandana, Singaram Kailash, Bathina Indira, Khan Mohd et al. (2023-08)
    Rheology and Pumpability of Mix Suitable for Extrusion-Based Concrete 3D Printing:
    A Review
  36. Zhang Nan, Sanjayan Jay (2023-08)
    Surfactants to Enable Quick Nozzle Mixing in 3D Concrete Printing
  37. Nguyen Ho, Thach Nguyen, Le Quang, Anh Yonghan (2023-07)
    A Review of Current Progress and Application of Machine Learning on 3D Printed Concrete
  38. Tu Haidong, Wei Zhenyun, Bahrami Alireza, Kahla Nabil et al. (2023-06)
    Recent Advancements and Future Trends in 3D Printing Concrete Using Waste-Materials
  39. Chen Hao, Zhang Daobo, Chen Peng, Li Ning et al. (2023-03)
    A Review of the Extruder System Design for Large-Scale Extrusion-Based 3D Concrete Printing
  40. Quah Tan, Tay Yi, Lim Jian, Tan Ming et al. (2023-03)
    Concrete 3D Printing:
    Process-Parameters for Process-Control, Monitoring and Diagnosis in Automation and Construction
  41. Li Mingyang, Liu Zhixin, Ho Jin, Wong Teck (2023-03)
    Improving Homogeneity of 3D Printed Cementitious Material-Distribution for Radial Tool-Path
  42. Geng Songyuan, Luo Qiling, Liu Kun, Li Yunchao et al. (2023-02)
    Research Status and Prospect of Machine Learning in Construction 3D Printing
  43. Tuvayanond Wiput, Prasittisopin Lapyote (2023-02)
    Design for Manufacture and Assembly of Digital Fabrication and Additive Manufacturing in Construction:
    A Review
  44. Yang Liming, Sepasgozar Samad, Shirowzhan Sara, Kashani Alireza et al. (2022-12)
    Nozzle Criteria for Enhancing Extrudability, Buildability and Inter-Layer Bonding in 3D Printing Concrete
  45. Nguyen Vuong, Li Shuai, Liu Junli, Nguyen Kien et al. (2022-11)
    Modelling of 3D Concrete Printing Process:
    A Perspective on Material and Structural Simulations
  46. Teixeira João, Schaefer Cecília, Rangel Bárbara, Maia Lino et al. (2022-11)
    A Road Map to Find in 3D Printing a New Design Plasticity for Construction:
    The State of Art
  47. Pan Tinghong, Guo Rongxin, Jiang Yaqing, Ji Xuping et al. (2022-11)
    Flow and Deformation Behaviors of Cementitious Materials Through Nozzles with Different Geometric Parameters:
    Experimental and Numerical Approaches
  48. Raza Muhammad, Zhong Ray (2022-08)
    A Sustainable Roadmap for Additive Manufacturing Using Geopolymers in Construction Industry
  49. Inaty Francois, Baz Bilal, Aouad Georges (2022-07)
    Long-Term Durability-Assessment of 3D Printed Concrete
  50. Buswell Richard, Xu Jie, Becker Daniel, Dobrzanski James et al. (2022-04)
    Geometric Quality Assurance for 3D Concrete Printing and Hybrid Construction Manufacturing Using a Standardised Test Part for Benchmarking Capability
  51. Pan Tinghong, Teng Huaijin, Liao Hengcheng, Jiang Yaqing et al. (2022-03)
    Effect of Shaping Plate Apparatus on Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Cement-Based Materials:
    Experimental and Numerical Studies
  52. Reinold Janis, Nerella Venkatesh, Mechtcherine Viktor, Meschke Günther (2022-02)
    Extrusion-Process-Simulation and Layer-Shape-Prediction During 3D Concrete Printing Using the Particle-Finite-Element-Method
  53. Nair Sooraj, Sant Gaurav, Neithalath Narayanan (2021-11)
    Mathematical Morphology-Based Point-Cloud-Analysis-Techniques for Geometry-Assessment of 3D Printed Concrete Elements
  54. He Lewei, Tan Jolyn, Chow Wai, Li Hua et al. (2021-11)
    Design of Novel Nozzles for Higher Inter-Layer Strength of 3D Printed Cement-Paste
  55. Zhang Nan, Xia Ming, Sanjayan Jay (2021-10)
    Short-Duration Near-Nozzle Mixing for 3D Concrete Printing
  56. Wi Kwangwoo, Wang Kejin, Taylor Peter, Laflamme Simon et al. (2021-09)
    Properties and Microstructure of Extrusion-Based 3D Printing Mortar Containing a Highly Flowable, Rapid Set Grout
  57. Wang Li, Ma Hui, Li Zhijian, Ma Guowei et al. (2021-07)
    Cementitious Composites Blending with High Belite-Sulfoaluminate and Medium-Heat Portland Cements for Large-Scale 3D Printing
  58. Marchment Taylor, Sanjayan Jay (2021-04)
    Reinforcement Method for 3D Concrete Printing Using Paste-Coated Bar Penetrations
  59. Lu Bing, Li Mingyang, Wong Teck, Qian Shunzhi (2021-02)
    Effect of Printing Parameters on Material-Distribution in Spray-Based 3D Concrete Printing (S-3DCP)
  60. Lao Wenxin, Li Mingyang, Tjahjowidodo Tegoeh (2020-09)
    Variable-Geometry Nozzle for Surface Quality Enhancement in 3D Concrete Printing
  61. Yang Huashan, Li Weiwei, Che Yujun (2020-08)
    3D Printing Cementitious Materials Containing Nano-CaCO3:
    Workability, Strength, and Microstructure

BibTeX
@article{lao_li_wong_tan.2020.ISFQiEB3CPUMLBEGC,
  author            = "Wenxin Lao and Mingyang Li and Teck Neng Wong and Ming Jen Tan and Tegoeh Tjahjowidodo",
  title             = "Improving Surface-Finish-Quality in Extrusion-Based 3D Concrete Printing Using Machine-Learning-Based Extrudate-Geometry-Control",
  doi               = "10.1080/17452759.2020.1713580",
  year              = "2020",
  journal           = "Virtual and Physical Prototyping",
  volume            = "15",
  number            = "2",
  pages             = "178--193",
}
Formatted Citation

W. Lao, M. Li, T. N. Wong, M. J. Tan and T. Tjahjowidodo, “Improving Surface-Finish-Quality in Extrusion-Based 3D Concrete Printing Using Machine-Learning-Based Extrudate-Geometry-Control”, Virtual and Physical Prototyping, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 178–193, 2020, doi: 10.1080/17452759.2020.1713580.

Lao, Wenxin, Mingyang Li, Teck Neng Wong, Ming Jen Tan, and Tegoeh Tjahjowidodo. “Improving Surface-Finish-Quality in Extrusion-Based 3D Concrete Printing Using Machine-Learning-Based Extrudate-Geometry-Control”. Virtual and Physical Prototyping 15, no. 2 (2020): 178–93. https://doi.org/10.1080/17452759.2020.1713580.