Skip to content

The Development of Soil-Based 3D Printable Mixtures (2023-06)

A Mix-Design Methodology and a Case Study

10.3390/buildings13071618

Daher Jana, Kleib Joelle, Benzerzour Mahfoud, Abriak Nor-Edine,  Aouad Georges
Journal Article - Buildings, Vol. 13, Iss. 7, No. 1618

Abstract

Concrete 3D printing is one of the newest technologies in the field of construction. However, despite the various opportunities that this technique offers today, it still has a high environmental impact, as most 3D-printable materials contain high amounts of cement. On the other hand, due to the large volumes of soil excavated each year across the world, there is a pressing need for proper management to dispose of it or reuse it efficiently. This study aims to develop sustainable and resistant 3D-printable materials with low environmental impact using excavated soil. Firstly, a series of tests were carried out to find the most appropriate superplasticizer and the amount required to develop the printable mixtures. Next, the extrudability and buildability were evaluated and verified to validate the printability of the developed mixtures. A 3D laboratory printer was also used to validate the printability of the mixtures on a larger scale. Then, the fresh and hardened properties of the printable mixtures were investigated. Three printable mixtures were developed, with the most environmentally friendly mixture having a soil content of 1602 kg/m3 and a cement content of 282 kg/m3. The mixtures demonstrated satisfactory characteristics and properties in both fresh and hardened states. On the one hand, the mixtures were extrudable and buildable at two laboratory scales. On the other hand, the mixtures presented sufficient compressive strengths, ranging from 16 MPa to 34 MPa, despite their high soil content and low cement content. In addition, their compressive strengths were found to be higher than the minimum strength required for structural concrete. Consequently, this study highlights the possibility of developing ecological, sustainable and resistant mixtures that can be used in 3D-printing construction applications using excavated soil.

43 References

  1. Alhumayani Hashem, Gomaa Mohamed, Soebarto Veronica, Jabi Wassim (2020-06)
    Environmental Assessment of Large-Scale 3D Printing in Construction:
    A Comparative Study between Cob and Concrete
  2. Arunothayan Arun, Nematollahi Behzad, Ranade Ravi, Bong Shin et al. (2021-02)
    Fiber-Orientation Effects on Ultra-High-Performance Concrete Formed by 3D Printing
  3. Asprone Domenico, Menna Costantino, Bos Freek, Salet Theo et al. (2018-06)
    Rethinking Reinforcement for Digital Fabrication with Concrete
  4. Batikha Mustafa, Jotangia Rahul, Baaj Mohamad, Mousleh Ibrahim (2021-12)
    3D Concrete Printing for Sustainable and Economical Construction:
    A Comparative Study
  5. Baz Bilal, Rémond Sébastien, Aouad Georges (2021-01)
    Influence of the Mix Composition on the Thixotropy of 3D Printable Mortars
  6. Bos Freek, Wolfs Robert, Ahmed Zeeshan, Salet Theo (2016-08)
    Additive Manufacturing of Concrete in Construction:
    Potentials and Challenges of 3D Concrete Printing
  7. Chen Yu, Li Zhenming, Figueiredo Stefan, Çopuroğlu Oğuzhan et al. (2019-04)
    Limestone and Calcined-Clay-Based Sustainable Cementitious Materials for 3D Concrete Printing:
    A Fundamental Study of Extrudability and Early-Age Strength Development
  8. Chen Yu, Rodríguez Claudia, Li Zhenming, Chen Boyu et al. (2020-07)
    Effect of Different Grade Levels of Calcined Clays on Fresh and Hardened Properties of Ternary-Blended Cementitious Materials for 3D Printing
  9. Chen Mingxu, Yang Lei, Zheng Yan, Huang Yongbo et al. (2020-04)
    Yield-Stress and Thixotropy-Control of 3D Printed Calcium-Sulfoaluminate Cement Composites with Metakaolin Related to Structural Build-Up
  10. Daher Jana, Kleib Joelle, Benzerzour Mahfoud, Abriak Nor-Edine et al. (2022-09)
    Recycling of Flash-Calcined Dredged Sediment for Concrete 3D Printing
  11. D'Haese Romain, Carpentier Olivier, Dubois Vincent, Chafei Sawsen et al. (2022-10)
    3D Printable Materials Made with Industrial Byproducts:
    Formulation, Fresh and Hardened Properties
  12. Feng Peng, Meng Xinmiao, Chen Jian-Fei, Ye Lieping (2015-06)
    Mechanical Properties of Structures 3D Printed with Cementitious Powders
  13. Hambach Manuel, Volkmer Dirk (2017-02)
    Properties of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Portland-Cement-Paste
  14. Han Yilong, Yang Zhihan, Ding Tao, Xiao Jianzhuang (2020-08)
    Environmental and Economic Assessment on 3D Printed Buildings with Recycled Concrete
  15. İlcan Hüseyin, Şahin Oğuzhan, Kul Anil, Yıldırım Gürkan et al. (2022-03)
    Rheological Properties and Compressive Strength of Construction and Demolition Waste-Based Geopolymer Mortars for 3D Printing
  16. Kaushik Sandipan, Sonebi Mohammed, Amato Giuseppina, Perrot Arnaud et al. (2022-02)
    Influence of Nano-Clay on the Fresh and Rheological Behavior of 3D Printing Mortar
  17. Kazemian Ali, Yuan Xiao, Cochran Evan, Khoshnevis Behrokh (2017-04)
    Cementitious Materials for Construction-Scale 3D Printing:
    Laboratory Testing of Fresh Printing Mixture
  18. Khalil Noura, Aouad Georges, Cheikh Khadija, Rémond Sébastien (2017-09)
    Use of Calcium-Sulfoaluminate-Cements for Setting-Control of 3D Printing Mortars
  19. Klyuev Sergey, Klyuev Alexander, Fediuk Roman, Ageeva Marina et al. (2022-04)
    Fresh and Mechanical Properties of Low-Cement Mortars for 3D Printing
  20. Le Thanh, Austin Simon, Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard et al. (2012-01)
    Hardened Properties of High-Performance Printing Concrete
  21. Le Thanh, Austin Simon, Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard et al. (2012-01)
    Mix-Design and Fresh Properties for High-Performance Printing Concrete
  22. Liu Zhixin, Li Mingyang, Weng Yiwei, Wong Teck et al. (2018-12)
    Mixture-Design-Approach to Optimize the Rheological Properties of the Material Used in 3D Cementitious Material-Printing
  23. Liu Chao, Wang Xianggang, Chen Yuning, Zhang Chao et al. (2021-06)
    Influence of Hydroxypropyl-Methylcellulose and Silica-Fume on Stability, Rheological Properties, and Printability of 3D Printing Foam-Concrete
  24. Long Wujian, Lin Can, Tao Jie-Lin, Ye Taohua et al. (2021-02)
    Printability and Particle-Packing of 3D Printable Limestone-Calcined-Clay-Cement Composites
  25. Ma Guowei, Li Zhijian, Wang Li (2017-12)
    Printable Properties of Cementitious Material Containing Copper-Tailings for Extrusion-Based 3D Printing
  26. Nematollahi Behzad, Xia Ming, Sanjayan Jay (2017-07)
    Current Progress of 3D Concrete Printing Technologies
  27. Panda Biranchi, Lim Jian, Tan Ming (2019-02)
    Mechanical Properties and Deformation Behavior of Early-Age Concrete in the Context of Digital Construction
  28. Panda Biranchi, Paul Suvash, Tan Ming (2017-07)
    Anisotropic Mechanical Performance of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Sustainable Construction-Material
  29. Panda Biranchi, Ruan Shaoqin, Unluer Cise, Tan Ming (2018-11)
    Improving the 3D Printability of High-Volume Fly-Ash Mixtures via the Use of Nano-Attapulgite-Clay
  30. Paul Suvash, Tay Yi, Panda Biranchi, Tan Ming (2017-08)
    Fresh and Hardened Properties of 3D Printable Cementitious Materials for Building and Construction
  31. Perrot Arnaud, Rangeard Damien, Courteille Eric (2018-04)
    3D Printing of Earth-Based Materials:
    Processing Aspects
  32. Perrot Arnaud, Rangeard Damien, Pierre Alexandre (2015-02)
    Structural Build-Up of Cement-Based Materials Used for 3D Printing-Extrusion-Techniques
  33. Puzatova (nee Sharanova) Anastasiia, Shakor Pshtiwan, Laghi Vittoria, Dmitrieva Maria (2022-11)
    Large-Scale 3D Printing for Construction Application by Means of Robotic Arm and Gantry 3D Printer:
    A Review
  34. Qian Ye, Schutter Geert (2018-06)
    Enhancing Thixotropy of Fresh Cement-Pastes with Nano-Clay in Presence of Polycarboxylate-Ether Superplasticizer (PCE)
  35. Rahul Attupurathu, Santhanam Manu, Meena Hitesh, Ghani Zimam (2018-12)
    3D Printable Concrete:
    Mixture-Design and Test-Methods
  36. Robayo-Salazar Rafael, Gutiérrez Ruby, Villaquirán-Caicedo Mónica, Delvasto Arjona Silvio (2022-12)
    3D Printing with Cementitious Materials:
    Challenges and Opportunities for the Construction Sector
  37. Sakin Mehmet, Kiroglu Yusuf (2017-10)
    3D Printing of Buildings:
    Construction of the Sustainable Houses of the Future by BIM
  38. Schutter Geert, Lesage Karel, Mechtcherine Viktor, Nerella Venkatesh et al. (2018-08)
    Vision of 3D Printing with Concrete:
    Technical, Economic and Environmental Potentials
  39. Valente Marco, Sibai Abbas, Sambucci Matteo (2019-09)
    Extrusion-Based Additive Manufacturing of Concrete Products:
    Revolutionizing and Remodeling the Construction Industry
  40. Wolfs Robert, Bos Freek, Salet Theo (2019-03)
    Hardened Properties of 3D Printed Concrete:
    The Influence of Process Parameters on Inter-Layer Adhesion
  41. Yao Yue, Hu Mingming, Maio Francesco, Cucurachi Stefano (2019-08)
    Life Cycle Assessment of 3D Printing Geopolymer Concrete:
    An Ex‐Ante Study
  42. Zhang Jingchuan, Wang Jialiang, Dong Sufen, Yu Xun et al. (2019-07)
    A Review of the Current Progress and Application of 3D Printed Concrete
  43. Zhang Yu, Zhang Yunsheng, Liu Guojian, Yang Yonggan et al. (2018-04)
    Fresh Properties of a Novel 3D Printing Concrete Ink

9 Citations

  1. Iqbal Imtiaz, Kasim Tala, Besklubova Svetlana, Inqiad Waleed et al. (2025-12)
    Exploring Knowledge Domains and Future Research Directions in 3D Printed Concrete:
    A Bibliometric and Systematic Review
  2. Tinoco Matheus, Lima Moura Paiva Rayane, Andrade Luiza, Mendoza Reales Oscar (2025-12)
    Hybrid 3D Printable Mixtures Incorporating Fine Earth, Portland Cement, and Fly Ash:
    A Sustainable Alternative to Cement-Intensive Systems
  3. Yousaf Arslan, Rashid Ans, Koç Muammer (2025-09)
    Additive Manufacturing for Vernacular Architecture Using Local Earthen Soil and Bio-Waste Materials
  4. Gerges Isabelle, Farraj Faten, Youssef Nicolas, Antczak Emmanuel et al. (2025-07)
    Methodologies to Design Optimum 3D Printable Mortar Mix:
    A Review
  5. Kumar Sandeep, Kumar Abhishek, Pundir Aakanksha, Dwivedi Ashutosh et al. (2025-06)
    Low-Clay Soil as Fine Aggregate in 3D Printed Concrete:
    Insights into Fresh and Hardened Properties
  6. Tarhan Yeşim, Tarhan İsmail, Jacquet Yohan, Perrot Arnaud (2024-09)
    Mechanical Behavior of 3D Printed and Textile-Reinforced Eco-Friendly Composites
  7. Souza Eduarda, Ribeiro Borges Paulo, Stengel Thorsten, Nematollahi Behzad et al. (2024-03)
    3D Printed Sustainable Low-Cost Materials for Construction of Affordable Social Housing in Brazil:
    Potential, Challenges, and Research Needs
  8. Buson Márcio, Varum Humberto, Rezende Marco (2024-01)
    First Impressions on Three-Dimensional Printing with Earth-Based Mortar at the Faculty of Engineering of the University of Porto
  9. Rocha Douglas, Faria Paulina, Lucas Sandra (2023-12)
    Additive Manufacturing of Earth-Based Materials:
    A Literature Review on Mortar-Composition, Extrusion, and Processing Earth

BibTeX
@article{dahe_klei_benz_abri.2023.TDoSB3PM,
  author            = "Jana Daher and Joelle Kleib and Mahfoud Benzerzour and Nor-Edine Abriak and Georges Aouad",
  title             = "The Development of Soil-Based 3D Printable Mixtures: A Mix-Design Methodology and a Case Study",
  doi               = "10.3390/buildings13071618",
  year              = "2023",
  journal           = "Buildings",
  volume            = "13",
  number            = "7",
  pages             = "1618",
}
Formatted Citation

J. Daher, J. Kleib, M. Benzerzour, N.-E. Abriak and G. Aouad, “The Development of Soil-Based 3D Printable Mixtures: A Mix-Design Methodology and a Case Study”, Buildings, vol. 13, no. 7, p. 1618, 2023, doi: 10.3390/buildings13071618.

Daher, Jana, Joelle Kleib, Mahfoud Benzerzour, Nor-Edine Abriak, and Georges Aouad. “The Development of Soil-Based 3D Printable Mixtures: A Mix-Design Methodology and a Case Study”. Buildings 13, no. 7 (2023): 1618. https://doi.org/10.3390/buildings13071618.